The First Reaction: Atlanta United vs Charlotte FC

Atlanta United midfielder Dax McCarty #13 dribbles during the first half of the match against the Charlotte FC at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta, GA on Sunday June 2, 2024. (Photo by Madelaina Polk/Atlanta United)

Atlanta United returned home Sunday afternoon for a southeastern Crown and Coke derby vs Charlotte FC, and came away with a 3-2 loss. It was the last match in a rough stretch for the Five Stripes before June’s international break, which will see a slew of players head off on duty for their respective countries. Unfortunately, any momentum from that match in Miami seems to have worn off quickly and we’re now in for an interesting two weeks before Atlanta United return to action.

When it rains, it pours

The Five Stripes started off this match versus Charlotte completely on the front foot and had multiple chances early on. They were able to bend in the defense but it never felt as if they were playing safe, but the VAR decision to give Charlotte their first goal took a lot of air out of the team. It cascaded miserably from there, as Charlotte tacked on two more.

Charlotte’s two latter goals were a series of miscommunications via Atlanta’s defense where Abada had time to tee up super accurate shots. He made the Five Stripes pay and definitely gave them a hole to dig out of, but the addition of Xande Silva – and his subsequent goal – gave Atlanta a lifeline. However, it simply wasn’t enough, nor should they have been in that position to begin with. In front of 61000 fans, coming off a huge win vs Miami…it simply has to be better across the board.

“Clear and obvious”

It’s amazing that this sport, like many others, has a governing body and set of rules and laws that go along with it.

We can argue until our faces are blue whether it was a goal or not, but until I see an angle that proves number three in that screenshot, why do we have a governing body and set of rules and laws to go with it?

Reset

Whether it was a win or loss tonight, Atlanta United desperately needed to get to this international break. This club can’t continue in this direction, and no matter what may happen in the next two weeks, something has to change. A massive reset is needed to get the Five Stripes back on the right track, and though it’s a massive, massive hill to climb, this season isn’t over yet.

A five game home losing streak is simply unheard of for this team, and quite frankly it’s unacceptable. I’m not trying to beat a dead horse here, nor am I trying to be negative, but it simply has to get better. Here’s hoping this break can lead to a significant reset. With news of Giorgos Giakoumakis potentially leaving for Cruz Azul running rampant and a feeling of uncertainty around the club, it seems like the next couple of weeks could be a roller coaster. Who knows?

Let us know down below what y’all think as the club heads into a period of rest and reflection.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

38 Comments
Clueless Joe

I thought we should have been up 3-1 at the half, but we can’t finish. The Charlotte VAR goal probably was a goal, but it definitely should not have deflated the team like it obviously did. If anything, it should have pissed them off. Instead, we stopped paying attention on defense and allowed two wide-open shots that were, of course, converted.

In other words, another day ending in “y”.

The team made the right decision today letting Pineda go. The same mistakes have been happening for far too long.

Pinedas Revenge

Happy now? All complaints no solution. With this roster please list the managers closely associated with a style of play for our current roster

Since we have so many that wanted him out who do you want in?

Robpar

Best wishes for Pineda and his family. He tried hard and hope he does well

T. Brian Nix

“but it has to get better” LMAO
Tyler, Wake up! Clearly, you are suffering some state of delusion. An organization CANNOT exceed the capacities of its leadership. This organization is leaderless! Is it not clearly obvious, as the players wander aimlessly for 90 minutes each week? Reality check, Tyler…this team is bad, the coach is bad, the FO is lost for resolutions and any contemplation for Five Stripe glory in 2024 is psychological dysfunction.

Andy W

Someone was questioning my use of the term “shambles” when it comes to ATL United defending. May I present exhibit A.

Last edited 2 years ago by Andy W
VAMOS ATLANTA

The headline I’m hoping to see later today: ATLANTA UNITED MANAGER GONZOLO PINEDA SACKED AFTER 5 GAMES LOST AT HOME IN A ROW AND TERRIBLE FORM! THE FANS HAVE GONE INTO THE STREETS OF DOWNTOWN ATLANTA AND CELEBRATED THEIR FIRST TRIUMPH IN MONTHS!!!

schyoo

^AND TECHNICAL DIRECTOR CARLOS BOCANEGRA

augoat

I’ve wanted him gone but it seems like he’s back to a more secondary role on player signings with Lagerwey here.

dmanatunga

Your wish was granted.

augoat

We got it. Time to get a winner.

VAMOS ATLANTA

YESS LET’S GO. I kind of feel bad celebrating this but to be fair, a 34-34-29 record or whatever it was isn’t of the Atlanta United standard. I think Pineda is a really nice guy but it had to be done.

Robpar

Agree with all of you. Is there anything we haven’t tried yet?
my only consolation is that suffering builds character. I have lots of character now. More character building for the next few months?

chrisjonesatl

The ball from the middle CB out over the top to Lennon and Wiley, over the opposing FB. It was there literally all day, and they tried it once….Lennon and Saba were begging for it.

But Wiley not even pretending to make that run means that they are being told not to do it.

WestCoastATLien

Charlotte did to us what we did to Miami.

Pineda gave us exactly what we wanted by not changing anything. But yet again, the other team makes a simple halftime adjustment (in this case, pressing higher), and we cant cope.

Pineda isnt THE problem, but he certainly isnt part of the solution.

Beyond that, I still have concerns that we just simply dont have the quality to deal with the average scrappy MLS team.

Southern_Azzurri

I mentioned this after the Miami game because I was not entirely convinced. We are incredible when we have space, yet struggle mightily when pressed and the game is physical. This game perfectly captured both of those situations.

dmanatunga

It sucks that it is illegal for tactical genius Pineda to also make adjustments against the opponents after the half. If it weren’t for that, so many games we could have won. Instead of focusing in getting rid of Pineda, us haters need to focus on changing the rules so that MLS games are only ine half.

chrisjonesatl

This is both slightly off and correct.

While our personnel selection was different and what we wanted, the tactical offensive positioning was exactly the same as before.

Teams absolutely can press us because we refuse to make them honor the ball over the top….and I’m not talking a long ball to holdup. That’s mediocre play at best.

CelticBhoy

At this point can you even fault GG for wanting to leave?

VAMOS ATLANTA

Pain pain go away come back another day when I am dead and in my grave and I don’t support this crap team.

JosefBetterThanCarlos

LOL

Blue Spark

I figured the Miami game was a mirage. The most frustrating thing about this team is the inconsistency.
There’s no way they give Pineda a new contract, so why keep him around? This season is a bust; cut him loose.

Mic

On the MARTA train wondering if this is worth it. No it is not.

augoat

MARTA is almost never worth it.

JosefBetterThanCarlos

The one time I used Marta, I was interning in midtown and went to a game with a friend. We used Marta on the way back. The first time the doors opened two guys were just beating the crap out of each other on the platform. Haven’t used it since lol

Clueless Joe

MARTA is not a fun ride from the Benz to Gwinnett.

SamH

I think I may be done with this for a while. Applying the Maria Kondo method, this doesn’t spark joy.

Gatorsnake

It’s just a shame. The offense actually looked better today. And then you have to sub Williams and Gregerson out and the defense goes to shit. Looking at the game individually you could say we just were unlucky. But 5 home losses in a row…. only one win in 11 games. That’s rough.

Sionnagh

It looks like literally everything has gone against AUFC that possibly could: VAR decisions, injuries, poor finishing, insane schedule congestion. They’re creating big chances but not getting goals. They’re defending well but their opponents seem to be able to put in low-chance shots at will. When your opponents regularly walk in and convert 50%+ of SoT to goals and your team converts 25% or less, something is just plain wrong. It may be Pineda, it may be key players, it may be the technical staff. I doubt there is a magic bullet here much to the chagrin of the Pineda/Boca out groups, and there is enough going right that the burn it all down crew is probably over reacting as well.

At the end of the day it is the job of the FO to figure it out and frankly see what’s beyond the stat sheet. This next two weeks I feel will be extremely telling as to what their conclusions are.

Blue Spark

Nonsense. These are the same issues all teams face. Others just handle it better. After 17 games, or rather 3 years, it’s not bad luck. This is Pineda’s (and Boca’s) team. This is what they built, and these are the results. It STILL doesn’t work.

Rightwing

100%. Pineda and Boca need to go… and post haste. Another season, another broken promise. Rinse, wash, repeat. I expect BIG changes or I’m done with AU.

chrisjonesatl

I mean….Stian was mostly awesome. But Williams was wildly at fault for the first two goals and Stian was caught ball watching on the third.

Angry Rodent II

I am so tired. Just…I got nothing.

Mia San Atl

Our lowest previous home PPG for a full season was 1.7. In the shitshow that was 2020, we had 1.4 home PPG. We’re at 1.1 now.

Bananatoes

Miami was the exception , not the rule.

We are what we are after this many games – not good. We are the same as last year – not good.

Not a big fan of fire the coach but at this point what else do you need to see? How many permutations of losing do you need.

Mic

Miami was the infamous “dead cat bounce “.

JosefBetterThanCarlos

Last year we WERE good though. That’s why I’m so confused. How did we even get here?

dmanatunga

I thought we were more lucky than good. Or at the least, a lot of players were overperforming. I think back on the Almada golazos and other last minute goals that saved us. Or thinking how Lennon had a ton of assists, but a lot of them were on set pieces. Now we have Almada barely scoring and we haven’t had a set piece goal in 17 matches.

I also remember saying this last season on DSS when we were still unsure about playoffs. My biggest worry would be that repeat the end of Pineda’s first half season, limp into the playoffs and get knocked out in the first round, and that would be used to justify his continued coaching. And here we are.

chrisjonesatl

not no mo

38
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x